Coming in fourth on my list of the best Turkey Hill ice cream flavors is the good old Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. This ice cream has a chocolate base with swirls of roasted peanut butter.

Graeter's caramel flavor is more subtle. Steve's is tasty vanilla ice cream with salty, buttery caramel swirls, and it tastes freshly made. Turkey Hill is also vanilla with swirls, but it's ...

It’s worth noting, there is an $8.85 million class-action settlement open against Breyer’s over the company’s use of artificial vanilla flavors in its “Natural Vanilla” ice cream.