If you happen to have one of these rare Beanie Babies, it might be time to put it on the auction block as you could come out ...

Beanie Babies sit on the shelf of a variety store. (Credit: JOYCE NALTCHAYAN/AFP via Getty Images) These toys were released in limited quantities, making them more desirable for collectors.

Some rare Beanie Babies were sold for thousands of dollars at their peak. Beanie Babies sit on the shelf of a variety store. (Credit: JOYCE NALTCHAYAN/AFP via Getty Images) These toys were released in ...

You can buy one of these plushies on the Ty website. Cookie is technically a "Beanie Bellie" (an offshoot line of Ty's Beanie Babies). He goes for just under four dollars online. As far as in-store ...