But let's talk about that Karo syrup, because there's a good chance you'll use it for your pie, put the cap back on the bottle, tuck the bottle in the cabinet, and then forget about it.

If you are on the prowl for an easy homemade soft caramel recipe without corn syrup ... unsalted butter, karo syrup, dark corn syrup or light corn syrup needed. Just 100% pure cane white sugar.