The difference-maker? Formulation, which determines how effective a product is and what its ingredients actually do to your hair. Clarifying shampoos, for example, use stronger surfactants (a.k.a ...

“For people with oily scalps without dandruff, I generally look for shampoos with ingredients like ... this under-$5 Neutrogena Anti-Residue Clarifying Shampoo is the way to go.