On the counter sits the real reason I’m here: a tin printed with snowflakes and snowmen and filled with stacks of stout and sparkly sugar-coated peanut butter ... ingredient off my bucket list ...

The ingredient list is simple ... keep natural peanut butter stocked in my pantry, smooth peanut butter spread, such as Skippy or Jif, is actually best here. That’s because it’s not as ...

These peanut butter cookies call for just four ingredients: sugar, peanut butter ... The best peanut butter for cookies is the processed creamy peanut butter, like JIF or Peter Pan. All-natural peanut ...

The recipe itself hinges on just a handful of ingredients, with peanut butter and chocolate ... like one from our ranked list of grocery store peanut butters. Our favorite is Jif Creamy, but ...