To find the best peanut butters you can get online or at the grocery store, we sampled 24 creamy and crunchy jars. Here are the blends that impressed us most.

Smooth peanut butter devotees, Jif Creamy Peanut Butter is the jar you want in your cupboard. Jif’s velvety texture had our Test Kitchen dipping their spoons in for a second taste right off the bat.