Breyers is undoubtedly one of the most popular ice cream brands in the United States. It all started with William A. Breyer hand-cranking his first gallon of ice cream in Philadelphia in 1866.

A 2024 lawsuit accused Breyers of using non-natural vanilla flavors in its natural vanilla ice cream. GETTY IMAGES Buyers duped by Breyers’ claims of “natural” flavors in its vanilla ice ...