A very popular fan theory during the run of The Penguin on HBO was that Sofia Falcone’s psychiatrist at Arkham, Dr. Julian Rush (Theo Rossi), was actually going to turn out to be Batman villain the ...

Be the first to know about your favorite movies, shows, comics, anime, video games, and more! Sign up here and never miss a scoop. By signing up, you confirm that you have read and agree to the ...

So, was Rush Scarecrow all along ... LeFranc decided against teasing some of the more infamous inmates from the comics. “Honestly, for [episode 4], we thought just about Sophia’s journey ...

However, evidence later surfaced (which you can see below) suggesting he was either meant to be Dr. Jonathan Crane or at least someone with close ties to Scarecrow. The Penguin's fourth episode ...